Klairs vs Skinfood: Which Black Sugar Scrub is Better?

by - December 31, 2017



Black sugar scrubs are quite popular nowadays as they do quite a great job exfoliating your skin. And all of us know how important exfoliating is since it gets rid of all of these flaky dead skin cells, that not only make your skin look dry and rough, but also makes your makeup look cakey and contributes alongside with the dirt to clog your pores, and thus cause more pimples and blackheads, I'm sure nobody wants this.
Personally, I have a dehydrated skin which means that my skin tends to produces more dead skin cells than the average person, and thus I need to exfoliate more often than those of you who have normal or oily skin. That's why, black sugar scrubs have been my dear friends for quite sometime now.

The two black sugar products I have used the most are Skinfood Black Sugar Wash Off Mask and Klairs Black Sugar Face Polish, and since they are some of the most popular scrubs on the marked, I decided to do a little comparison today. (let me know if you want me to review them separately for you guys ^^)

So here is a little comparison:

Here is a little close up:




Skin Food Black Sugar Wash Off Mask
Klairs Black Sugar Facial Polish
Price (in Korea)
7700won
10500won
Avalability
Almost everywhere
Only in Korea, or online on wishtrend and maybe some other online stores (less than a handful)
Volume
100g
110g (it was only 60g before)
Ingredients
Irritating
2
1
unsafe
4 (one of them rated 7)
5 (rated from 3 to 4)
Fragrance?
Yes
yes
Scent
Citrus (SOOOO STRONG I HATE IT)
Herbal or something. Not too strong
The size of the particles
small
smaller
Harshness
A liiitle bit harsh
Slightly harsher than the skinfood one
Time you should leave it on
10min
None
How soft your skin feels afterward
+
++
Other effects?
none
Kinda reduce blackheads, but nothing much


In Other words:

Reasons to buy Klairs:
- your skin is softer afterward
- doesn't have a suffocating scent
- kinda helps reducing blackheads (nothing much though)
- you don't have to wait 10 min
- Now comes in a large 110g jar

Reasons to buy Skin Food:
- More gentle on the skin
- You get a lot of product (100g) for a little price (around 10$)
- Considerably cheaper especially if you are buying it on line.


My thoughts:
For about 8 months now, whenever they would ask me what is you favorite black sugar scrub my automatic answer would be "KLAIRS Duh!" and I'll go on and on about how gentle and efficient it is in comparison with skinfood, but now that I used them side by side today, I feel like I've been lying to people this whole time saying that Klairs is more gentle when actually it is the harsher one here, so I feel like I owe you guys and explanation:
Skinfood was the first mechanical scrub I have ever used, and after accidentally purchasing 2 jars of the Klairs and receiving a third one for free, I practically abandoned The skinfood Black Sugar Scrub, and you can say that I forgot how it works except that my first impression was "oh this is quite harsh on the skin!". you would say "but you just said that Klairs' is harsher" well yeah you are right but then when I started using it I was already used to black sugar scrubs, so it felt quite gentle xD

What scrub do I prefer now?
Each of them has its cons and pros but I feel like Skinfood Sugar Scrub has a better quality-price ratio (I mean, it is really inexpensive), but if you aren't tight on budget, you might want to go for klairs.
Personally, I'll still go back to Klairs whenever I'll feel that my skin isn't scrubbed enough or when I wanna tone down my blackheads a notch or two. 

Where can you buy them?
- Skin Food Black Sugar Wash Off Mask Here* for $9.58
- Klairs Black Sugar Facial Polish Here* for $23 (use my invitation code: 125028803 to get $5 off your first purchase)


So What is your favorite one? lemme know in the comments below.

Don't forget to follow me on social media for more updates ^_^ 

Bloglovin: Glow With Mei
Facebook: Glow With Mei
Instagram: @Glowithmei
Pinterest: Glowithmei


Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. Clicking those links before you shop means that I will receive a small commission that wouldn't affect the price you pay, which helps to support this blog.

You May Also Like

6 comments

  1. I've been seeing Skin Food since last year but I never heard that they have this black sugar scrub. Thanks for this review!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think I would use Skinfood Sugar Scrub because of the better price. I have never used a sugar scrub before so it was interesting to learn about them.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I use a watermelon scrub but I have never tried a black sugar scrub before, although I have heard that they do wonders for your complexion. Do you by any chance know whether they are cruelty free?

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is a good review. I've never had Klairs. I tried skin food too before, 'cause it's cheaper and kinda works for me too :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. It's the first time I heard about black sugar scrub but I think but I'm guessing it's a great facial product for exfoliating the skin. Your honest review helps to decide which between Klairs and Skinfood suits our skin needs

    ReplyDelete
  6. I personally recommend Skin food, I'm a huge fan of Korean beauty products, and skinfood black sugar scrub works really well on my skin. Nice article!

    ReplyDelete